Why does Ralph leadership fail?
While Ralph proves in many ways a thoughtful, charismatic, and effective leader, his leadership is flawed by his indecision and inability to think clearly in crucial moments. Ralph’s unwillingness to resort to fear tactics and violence to lead the boys also makes him ultimately ineffective as a leader.
Why does Ralph think about quitting as leader Why does Piggy fear Ralph quitting as leader?
Expert Answers Piggy is adamantly against the notion of Ralph stepping down from being the chief. He reasons with Ralph that Jack respects him more. Piggy’s own well-being is his central interest in persuading Ralph to remain as the chief of the boys. Piggy fears what Jack might do without Ralph to stand in his way.
How does Ralph affirm his position of leadership over the group?
Ralph sees his authority being tied to making rules and keeping things in order. He is very pleased with the suggestion that the conch is a symbol of order. Ralph appreciates that the conch needs to be held in order for everyone to listen.
Why does Piggy want Ralph to give up leadership?
Ralph is interested in keeping the fire going and trying to be rescued above all else whereas Jack is just interested in meat and hunting. Also, Ralph is the only one who seems to care about Piggy – all the others just make fun of him. If Ralph gave up leadership, Piggy would be at the mercy of the others.
How is Ralph shown to be a good leader?
‘We’ve got to make smoke up there – or die.’” (Golding, 86-87). This quote displays how Ralph is attempting to maintain order and civilized behaviour. By being the first to tell them what to do and by showing initiative and by setting goals for the boys to follow, he prepares practical plans that will help the boys get rescued.
Why does Ralph want to quit being chief?
Unfortunately, Jack interrupts the entire assembly by not obeying the conch and ends up excusing his hunters without Ralph’s permission. Once Jack and his hunters leave the assembly in a frenzy, Ralph remarks that he ought to quit being chief.
Why does Piggy dissuade Ralph from giving up?
Once Jack and his hunters leave the assembly in a frenzy, Ralph remarks that he ought to quit being chief. Piggy immediately attempts to dissuade Ralph from giving up power by mentioning that Jack will surely destroy everything. Piggy tells Ralph, If Jack was chief he’d have all hunting and no fire. We’d be here till we died (Golding, 131).